Lyle’s rewritten six verse text is roughly parallel towards songster text immediately after removal of your own next verse of second. Lyle’s rewritten variation, not, has the regiment gonna Kilkenny, in lieu of Killarney. Lyle’s song are “The Bonnie Bluish Ignore-Me-Maybe not,” that has been offered inside the Roentgen. An excellent. Smith’s New Irish Minstrel , n.d. [1825, the first, supposedly suppressed, edition]. New name of your track will there be considering as “The newest Maid from Derby.” If you find yourself Lyle’s text message “Very Peg regarding Derby” is worthless because a timeless song, we could be certain that “Rather Peggy from Derby” was sung for the Scotland in the first quarter of one’s 19th century having a text very similar to you to definitely in the songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text message in the place of an excellent chapbook or broadside copy appears Roy Palmer’s present Everyman’s Publication of Ballads. ]
Cahusac inside 1788, and you can a single sheet tune with tunes is within one or two American choices, “Peggy off Darby”, and that commences “There is an excellent gay Head inside Darby Town”
Perhaps somewhat prior to “Rather Peggy out-of Derby, O” is actually rewritten due to the fact “The newest Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” due to the fact evidenced from the a duplicate from inside the Peter Buchan’s MSS on the Uk Collection, being believed to big date about 1828.
The first range . 5, almost like men and women a lot more than, also are in the a great medley in the Vol. We, p. 4, 1825. You’ll find audio to the tune “Very Peggy from Derby, O” toward p. 107 and 276 of Vol. III, 1828, in addition to first line from “Peggy out-of Darby” is during good medley on p. 284.
Lyle as well as authored yet another tune into the tune, considering about work quoted, and posted earlier that have tunes
T. Crofton Crocker on the Prominent Audio from Ireland , London, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 from 1886 reprint), states, “The fresh new pretty Maid out of Derby, O!” is known to be the production of why do white men like Salem, MA women a keen Irishman, however, become brings zero specifics whichever, not even bringing up where a duplicate of your text message or song will be discover. It appears that Crocker questioned his customers becoming familiar to the tune and you will track. Evidence cited significantly more than seems to me to become somewhat conclusive for taking “Rather Peggy off Derby” to get a keen Irish song and you will track. Devoid of it evidence, although not, there were counterclaims. Wm. Chappell during the Songs of Olden Day , II, p. 771, indexed Crocker’s claim, but meant your tune was not Irish, however, the guy supplied no lead facts. Chappell’s statement one to Bunting rejected it is without basis. Bunting failed to talk about the fresh song, that’s not the same as claiming he denied they. Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs that have Chappell within his summary of Irish Folk music in the latest fifth ed. of Grove’s Dictionary , however, cites zero evidence expert otherwise scam, therefore we don’t know what facts he previously seen, or no.
Finally, a couple items I have not yet seen. There is certainly a duplicate of the pay attention a beneficial flute teacher authored by T. BUCEM listing zero backup in the regarding the British Countries.
Unrelated: “Drops out-of Brandy” was a significantly old unrelated track away from equivalent identity, also known as “Dribbles out of Brandy.” The second identity Thomson’s track toward pay attention their Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Disturb Gallant’, 1738. Many years later which song try duplicated into the NLS MS 6299. The newest song you are going to admission with the fresh one to to the tune if we did not remember that the fresh new tune is prior to. “The Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s track to own their track “Younger Could possibly get Moonlight” within the 5th amount of Irish Melodies , n.d. try an alternate listen 6/8 big date having the same title, obviously provided by Moore regarding chorus of a tune within the Robin Hood where track searched in the place of identity.